Indian Legal System: Courts, Crime And The Power Of Money

In India’s complex legal system, a clear distinction exists between those who have power and money and those who do not. This disparity is most evident in cases of criminal justice and legal proceedings. Recent discussions have revealed disturbing truths about the judicial process, giving us a deeper understanding of how the system works, the terrible backlog of cases and the often traumatic experiences of those caught up in it.

Scenario Of Indian Justice

The Indian legal system has a huge backlog of cases, with over 45 million cases pending in lower courts. As a lawyer recently pointed out, if cases continued to be settled at the current pace without adding new cases, it could take some 300 years for this backlog to be eliminated. This shocking figure immediately brings out the need for reform and raises questions about the effectiveness of the judicial process itself.

Why do criminals roam free?

The process that should lead to justice often falters for several reasons:

Compromising witnesses: There are disturbing instances where witnesses are bribed or threatened, changing the course of justice.
Procedural failures: Police and investigative agencies often fail to follow necessary procedures, allowing accused to take advantage of shortcomings.
Money and influence: People who hold significant financial and political power often escape the consequences of their actions, creating the impression that money can buy freedom.

Take the case of a man who is involved in the murder and, while in prison, has the victim’s family commit a second murder in order to pressure them into a compromise. The release of this person is made easier by a corrupt judicial system that prefers wealth and influence to justice.

A Disturbing Truth Of Bail And Remand

For many people, justice is a difficult thing. With the facility of bail, people, even those accused of serious crimes, are easily freed. For example, it has been observed that people spend only a few months in jail for heinous crimes and still get bail easily, which is a sad proof of the laxity present in the system. As one lawyer summarized, “If you have money or connections, the law often looks the other way”

Shocking statistics

Statistics about the Indian justice system paint a grim picture:

76% of inmates are undertrials and many of them have not yet been proven guilty.
There are just 21 judges for every 10 million people in the country.
The effectiveness of the system depends largely on financial resources, which often alienate the poorer strata of society.

This system failure raises important questions about what it means to seek justice in a country where poor people are generally at the mercy of their rich counterparts.

Sad Stories Of Injustice

Examples drawn from actual experiences shed light on the harsh truth faced by those trapped in legal systems. One case is the tragic Morbi bridge collapse, in which 135 innocent people died. Despite this, an investigation has revealed that important people involved in the construction and maintenance of the bridge tried to avoid accountability.

Responses to these tragedies highlight a major concern about reparations measures. Families affected by such disasters often receive modest sums – ₹2 lakhs or ₹4 lakhs – for their deep losses, which is much less than the life of a loved one.

Raising voice for the victims, many families asked for full compensation of ₹1 crore for every deceased due to negligence of the authorities.

Role Of Corruption

The issue of corruption is most important in discussions about justice, which has been described as “India’s operating system”. This means that the intertwined forces of money, influence and power often dictate the outcome of legal proceedings.

Bribery and collusion: The ease with which wealth can manipulate legal processes has often been documented, with numerous examples of police, officials and even those in the judiciary allowing corruption to flourish at the expense of truth and morality.
Public sentiment and policy: In a society where the outcome of cases can often be dictated by an individual’s financial situation, demands for transparency and reform become even louder.

Advocacy For Change: The Way Forward

Given these challenges, what can be done to get on the right track? A multidimensional approach is suggested:

Special courts to deal with cases faster: Setting up special courts dedicated to dealing with rape cases faster, and ordering investigations to be completed within certain deadlines, could reduce delays that fuel injustice.
Campaign against corruption: Advocating tough policies to fight corruption at multiple levels of governance, ensuring legal action is taken against those found involved in such actions.
Better legal education: Investing in legal literacy for citizens, especially in rural areas, can help more people seek justice and understand their rights.

Conclusion

The Indian legal system is at a critical juncture where public opinion, the shortcomings of the system and the urgent need for reform are interconnected. As long as money and power continue to dominate the quest for justice, the ideals of fairness and equality will remain distant dreams for countless people. Accepting challenges and adopting the vision of a more just society is essential for collective future progress. Change starts with awareness and advocacy. Let us continue the dialogue how can we collectively work for meaningful reform of our legal system?

Read Also: